Accident-Only vs. Accident & Illness Pet Insurance

Last updated: November 18, 2026

An accident-only pet insurance plan covers injuries such as broken bones, bites or swallowed objects. An accident and illness plan covers those too, plus illnesses like infections, cancer and diabetes. Accident-only costs far less, averaging about $190 a year for dogs in 2025 versus $836 for accident and illness coverage, but it leaves out most of the big bills pets actually face.

The short version

Accident onlyAccident & illness
Average yearly cost, dog (2025)$190$836
Average yearly cost, cat (2025)$112$435
Injuries and emergencies from accidentsYesYes
Illnesses, including cancer and infectionsNoYes
Hereditary and chronic conditionsNoUsually, if not pre-existing
Routine careNoNo, unless you add a wellness plan
Accident-only plans cover injuries and swallowed objects; accident and illness plans also cover illnesses and hereditary conditions; neither covers routine care

Who accident-only plans suit

  • Tight budgets where any coverage is better than none.
  • Older pets whose accident and illness premiums would be very high.
  • Pets with several pre-existing conditions that illness coverage would exclude anyway.
  • Owners who can handle illness costs from savings but want help with sudden accidents.

Who should choose accident and illness

  • Young, healthy pets, because enrolling early means future illnesses aren’t pre-existing.
  • Breeds prone to costly conditions, such as joint, heart or breathing problems.
  • Owners without a large emergency fund, since illnesses like cancer can cost thousands.

Accident and illness plans are by far the most popular type in the U.S., largely because illnesses are a common reason for expensive vet visits.

Questions to ask before you choose

  • What counts as an “accident”? Some policies treat ligament tears as illnesses or orthopedic conditions with special waiting periods.
  • Are exam fees covered for accident claims?
  • Can you upgrade from accident-only later, and would new conditions then be pre-existing?
  • What are the waiting periods and annual limits?

For the basics of deductibles and reimbursement, read how pet insurance works, and see how much pet insurance costs.

Key takeaways

  • Accident-only plans cover injuries; accident and illness plans also cover sickness.
  • Accident-only averaged $190 a year for dogs in 2025, versus $836 for accident and illness.
  • Accident and illness is usually the better fit for young pets and breeds with known health risks.
  • Neither type covers routine care without a separate wellness add-on.
Accident-Only vs. Accident & Illness Pet Insurance - PetCostDesk
Save this guide on Pinterest for later.
AA

Written by Adrián Antón Valera

Founder and editor of PetCostDesk. Adrián writes plain-English guides to what pet care really costs, based on veterinary organizations, official data and published prices. Our guides are not a substitute for advice from your veterinarian.

↑